Wikipedia:Featured list candidates/List of AS Roma players

List of AS Roma players[edit]

Self-nom. It seems to me that the list meets all of the criteria. Furthermore it is copied from List of Arsenal F.C. players which is already featured. Gaúcho

Oppose

The majority of the entries in the list are redlinked. Criterion 1a of Wikipedia:What is a featured list? states A useful list must be composed of a large majority of links to existing articles (blue links).
Statistics are missing for several entries, with no explanation given.
The lead states that some players who have played fewer matches are also included; this includes some players who fell just short of the 100 total and players who made significant contributions to the club's history, but a significant number have less than 100 appearances, including several with less than 50.
The references are bare links with no formatting. A format such as the {{Cite web}} template should be used. Oldelpaso 19:09, 7 October 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Oppose Too many redlinks and no stats, as per Oldelpaso. King fish erswift 11:43, 8 October 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Oppose Too many redlinks, and too many of them have played fewer than 100 matches. Qwghlm 21:51, 8 October 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Neutral Stats are just enough for me to find it compelling, however the red-links are a little bit of a worry. I also recommend you add a "Records" or similar section, where you detail those from the list with the most caps, goals etc. The idea is to make it compelling to read :D Good luck, Daniel .Bryant 03:04, 9 October 2006 (UTC)[reply]